IWSG: Reading Differently

This is the IWSG post for March. The IWSG is a great group for writers at all stages, where we commune and discuss our writerly insecurities every first Wednesday of the month. March’s co-hosts are: Lauren Hennessy, Lisa Buie-Collard, Lidy, Christine Rains, and Mary Aalgaard! 

Years ago, a writing professor told me that the more I wrote, the more I read, the more I might not enjoy reading for the sake of reading as I used to, that writing more seriously would change the way I read things.

Y’all, it’s happened. I mean–it’s been happening. I know it has. It’s not that I’ve grown pickier over what I read–seeing what I’ve been reading laid out on Goodreads has actually shown me my own reading habits and forced me to go and find other things to read.

But I am a lot more critical of what I read. I decided to review every book I read this year, when in the years past, I only reviewed the ones I felt compelled to.

I read a historical romance last week and while the story was entertaining and I liked the lead characters, I was also mentally noting, “Hmm. Head hopping. Oh, omniscient point of view. Info Dump! Stilted dialogue. Really, would that character do that?”

A few weeks prior, I was reading a historical fiction called Tidewater when there was a sequence of sort-of supernatural-ish bits. They were there to illustrate the belief systems of the 16th century Native American character, but they stood out compared to the more authentic and grounded rest of the story.

None of this is to say that my writing, though it’s come along, is perfect. Pearl‘s first chapter is a bit info-dumpy. A short story I submitted last month for an upcoming anthology (The Thing That Turned Me–out May 31st!) definitely needs some editing and perhaps a touch of rewriting. Plotting is still a challenge. Finding the not-so-great bits of your own writing doesn’t happen as easily as finding it in someone else’s.

But having your writer helmet on while reading is super useful–but then again, if I’m reading something that blows my mind, the insecurity bell goes off in my head.

20 thoughts on “IWSG: Reading Differently

  1. I do pick apart what I read sometimes. I've been doing it for a long time. Books, movies, plays. There's no telling how many tangents friends and family have been subjected to over the years. That said, if something is amazing, I just go with it. After all, nothing is ever perfect. I'll forgive a lot of grievances if the story is good enough. One of my most favorite books of all time has this stupid scene in it where the main character starts speaking Italian for no reason, which of course the author has to translate, and to this day I still think it's pretentious and pointless. Kind of makes me wonder why she thought that was a good idea. The character wasn't Italian and up until that point, there was a bunch of fragmented French in the book, which now that I think about it, also makes no sense.

    Like

  2. It happened to me too.I don't enjoy reading the way I used to…Gone are the days when I'd simply switch off, shut out the world around me and lose myself in the story…Yes, reading mind-blowing stuff is a double-edged sword! *sigh*Happy IWSG Day!

    Like

  3. Wait, so the character wasn't Italian, didn't speak Italian up to that point, so…why was that there? Weird. I notice that I pick apart romance novels the most these days. Maybe because I've read them all this time, so I kind of know what the formula is.

    Like

  4. I enjoy reading–I love it–but my brain is definitely still going as I read and that can be annoying. It's less likely to do that in genres I don't read very much of, though, so I'm going to read some fantasy next.

    Like

  5. Seconded. But when I read something that blows my mind, I also pause to analyze what it is that got to me. Was it the concept? The characters? The way the story was told? It usually boils down to character for me. If I don't like the characters or the way they evolve, I will throw the book aside.

    Like

  6. It's happened to me too. I feel tempted to write notes in the margins of books about where the author could have tightened up the prose or tweaked some character development. I miss the days where I could lose myself in a novel. When I read something great, I find myself going back and looking for how the author built the story so well.

    Like

  7. Writing does change how you read, I think it helps me spot my errors when I see it in someone elses too. I also find myself noticing how writing styles have changed over the years – books I read in the 80's often seemed to have headhopping, perhaps it's become less acceptable over time (or maybe it's just the books I read then!)

    Like

  8. So wonderful you are part of that anthology, too!I notice those things, but what I really notice is how well a character grabs me. If it's not a really compelling character, if I don't relate, it dumps me out of the story so fast.

    Like

  9. Word choices jar me a lot. \”Why did they choose that word? Why not that one?\” When I read a novel that carries me along and I love, I try to figure out why I liked it so much, too.

    Like

  10. One of the writers I mentor told me recently that she saw a kids show and began picking it apart, pointing out what didn't make sense, much to the annoyment to the company she was with. She realized she had me to thank for that, as I kept challenging to break a story apart and really understand what things were. Now she's learning how to turn it off.I can't help but analyze what I read or what I watch, and I love that about myself, but it also means I can't just enjoy something for the entertainment its meant to be. I've come to accept that about myself.As I say to my proteges, it is a blessing and a curse.

    Like

  11. Yes, I do that, too. I have a hard time reading anything without the writer/editor part of my brain kicking in. And I know what you mean about the insecurities. When something's that good, I always think mine could never compare. Sometimes, you just can't win. 🙂

    Like

Leave a Reply to Unknown Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.